http://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article519.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article520.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article521.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article522.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article523.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article524.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article525.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article526.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article527.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article528.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article529.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article530.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article531.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article532.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article533.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article534.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article535.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article536.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article537.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article538.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article539.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article540.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article541.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article542.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article543.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article544.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article545.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article546.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article547.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article548.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article549.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article550.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article551.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article552.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article553.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article554.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article555.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article556.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article557.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article558.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article559.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article560.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article561.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article562.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article563.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article564.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article565.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article566.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article567.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article568.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article569.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article570.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article571.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article572.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article573.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article574.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article575.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article576.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article577.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article578.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article579.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article580.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article581.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article582.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article583.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article584.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article585.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article586.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article587.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article588.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article589.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article590.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article591.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article592.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article593.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article594.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article595.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article596.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article597.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article598.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article599.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article600.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article601.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article602.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article603.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article604.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article605.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article606.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article607.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article608.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article609.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article610.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article611.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article612.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article613.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article614.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article615.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article616.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article617.htmlhttp://www.haven.i-ti.org/forum/user/article618.html PhilC’s Ramblings » What makes a searchterm competitive?

What makes a searchterm competitive?

It amazes me how often we get posts in forums where the writers don’t have a clue as to what a competitive searchterm really is, so I thought I’d explain exactly what it is that makes a searchterm competitive.

The only thing that makes a searchterm competitive is when other people are actually competing for it; i.e. when they are optimising their pages and links for it. That’s all.

Here are some of the things that I’ve come across where people think a searchterm  is competitive, but it isn’t.

They think that a searchterm is competitive because a large number of results are returned for it. It isn’t. A search on Google for the word [the] currently returns 4.9 *billion* results, but does anyone compete for that searchterm? No. Alright, it would be very difficult to get a page into the top 10 for that single word, even though nobody actively competes for it, but it makes the point.

I saw a thread today where a person was saying how easy it is to rank #1 in Google in the face of competition, and he gave an example of his work. Sure enough, his page was ranked #1 out of 1.75 million results for a particular phrase. But when the phrase was searched in quotes, there were only 37 results; i.e. only 37 pages in Google’s entire index were concerned with that phrase. And only one of them (his page) actually put it in the page Title, so he was the only one who was taking steps to compete in that particular race. When you’re the only one in the race, it’s very easy to win! Overture shows a grand total of zero searches for the phrase during last month. Even though Google returns 1.75 million results, the phrase is totally uncompetitive. The thread is at the SearchEngineWatch forum, and the phrase is temporary stair access.

That’s the biggest thing that people get wrong. They mistakenly equate the number of results with competitiveness.

Another mistake that I’ve come across was somebody claiming certain phrases to be competitive, simply because they concerned a high finance industry - oil! His idea was that, because the oil industry deals in huge sums of money, the few companies that are in it must compete very heavily, and therefore industry phrases must be very competitive. He actually spent 25 pages of a forum thread arguing his case - but he was completely wrong.

The client site that he dealt with was on Google’s first results page for phrases like [rotating choking sleeve]. To demonstate how uncompetitive his phrases were, somebody simply wrote a page about one of them, which was in the top 10 within days. In the forum here, we have a thread about it, two pages of which are at #3 and #4 in Google - his client’s pages are at #5 and #6!

It’s not the number of results, or the amount of money in the industry, that makes a searchterm competitive. It’s the number of websites that are actually competing for it that matters. If only 11 websites in the entire Web are competing for a phrase, then one of them will always be left out of the top 10. The level of competition between the 11 can become very vigorous, but there will always be one that isn’t in the top 10. A phrase that returns many millions of results can be very uncompetitive because nobody is actually competing, whereas a phrase that returns very few results can be extrememly competitive because they are all competing vigorously. Competition makes a searchterm competitive, and that’s all.

Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • RawSugar
  • YahooMyWeb

11 Comments »

  1. SEM Basics said,

    November 6, 2006 @ 8:34 am

    Hello Phil,

    I am actually writing a few articles about this issue, the first of which is already done. It is called How to Analyze Your Keyword List and can be seen here: www.sembasics.com/sem-guides/keyword-strategies/keyword-analysis-for-seo. In the next few articles I plan to discuss how you analyze the top results in the search engine results to try and indicate the competitiveness of a word as well as discuss various tools which can be of assistance. I’ve admired your posts at SEW for a while now and have read and enjoyed some of the articles on your site and therefore would love to hear what you think of this article as well as the future ones(constructive criticsm welcomed). Any and all insights/ideas you have on the subject are welcomed and wanted.

    Thanks for raising the issue. It is a problem. The fact that some people and/or companies still use KEI contributes (I think) to the problem.

    All the best,

    Moshe
    SEM Basics

    P.S. Nice blog, I’ve just added it to my Google Reader.

  2. PhilC said,

    November 6, 2006 @ 8:55 am

    That’s an excellent article, Moshe! In fact I posted about it in the forum:-

    http://www.webworkshop.net/seoforum/viewtopic.php?t=14603

    Thank you for the kind comments, btw :)

  3. SEM Basics said,

    November 6, 2006 @ 9:34 am

    Uggghhh! I forgot to answer the math question and lost my comment!

    Well, in short, I’m glad you liked it. If anyone wants to further discuss this issue (either here or in the forum) I’d love to hear what people have to say.

    Take care,

    Moshe
    SEM Basics

  4. Neale said,

    November 6, 2006 @ 9:37 am

    Thanks Phil & Moshe great articles !

  5. vishnusankar said,

    November 10, 2006 @ 8:57 am

    Hello Phil
    I saw this article link which was post by U at your forum ok and thanks for your great information and your work.

  6. Druid said,

    November 16, 2006 @ 12:46 pm

    Yes, and perhaps ‘Scaffolding Stair Access’ is a more appropriate phrase, or maybe even ‘Scaffold Stair Access’ . I have read the articles and the Blogs and it occurs to me that the author of the site was acting on his/her customers instruction. However just how relavent are those keywords. ?

    The answer must be that ‘Temporay Stair Access’ is not very relevent at all. Where as, ‘Scaffolding Stair Access’ & ‘Scaffold Stair Access’ are. Lets face it, should someone in the UK scaffold industry want such a product those are the key words that they would most likely use.

    So i tried ‘Scaffolding Stair Access’ & ‘Scaffold Stair Access’ (without quotation marks, because most people do not use them when searching. And both came number one in Google, above all their UK competitors. ‘Scaffolding Stair Access’ & ‘Temporary Stair Access’ are also number one in Yahoo.

    There seems to be a little jealousy going on, a lot of knocking the success. But say what you will the designer of the site has met his/her customers needs.

  7. PhilC said,

    November 16, 2006 @ 1:24 pm

    There seems to be a little jealousy going on, a lot of knocking the success

    There’s no jealousy at all, and no reason for any.

    But say what you will the designer of the site has met his/her customers needs.

    I disagree with that. The person may well have met the client’s desires, but definitely not his needs. Let’s have a look at those two alternatives that you suggested.

    There is a massive two pages in Google’s entire index that contain the words in Scaffold Stair Access in their Titles, and neither of them have them in the right order. And there’s a whopping one page in Google’s entire index that has Scaffold Stair Access in its Title - again, not in the right order. In fact there are exactly zero pages in Google’s entire index that are actually targeting those phrases.

    So what about those phrases in page content? Well, there’s a grand total of one page in Google’s entire index that has the phrase Scaffolding Stair Access in it, and even then it’s just coincidence that the words are adjacent because they are split by a grammatical comma. And there are a mere 40 pages containing the phrase Scaffold Stair Access.

    Or, to put it another way, those phrases are just about as uncompetitive as you can get.

    Now, when ascertaining a client’s “needs”, an seo must go for high search engine rankings for phrases that people actually search on when looking for what the client has to offer. It doesn’t make any difference if the phrases are uncompetitive as long as people actually search on them in reasonable numbers. During last month, only 27 people search the whole of Overture.com and its partners for scaffold stair access, and zero people searched it for scaffolding stair access. The numbers for the UK are a lot less of course. So, whilst the client may get a few handfuls of visitors from top rankings for those phrases, there must be other phrases that will do better, and he really needs the best ones.

    The point of this thread isn’t whether or not an seo did his/her job properly - it’s about what makes a searchterm competitive, and none of the phrases are in any way competitive. I notice that you said your two phrases are more relevant, and they may be, and you didn’t suggest that they are competitive.

  8. » Hidden stair access followup - Marciahoo said,

    November 20, 2006 @ 9:12 pm

    […] On Nov. 6th a post was done on hidden stair access concerning how to tell how competitive phrases are for search results. What’s interesting is that there was a link to the Google search for it in a Search Engine Watch thread, and PhilC also did a commentary on the hidden stair access competive issue at his forum, which can be found linked to from the Google Search result for the phrase, as well as on his blog. […]

  9. PhilC said,

    November 20, 2006 @ 9:25 pm

    Hi Marcia.

    Google’s current top three rankings for [temporary stair access] are very interesting. Since the discussion came up at SEW, that thread has gained the #1 ranking, the thread in the forum here has gained the #2 ranking, and for good measure, the RSS feed containing the blog post here has got the #3 ranking - all ahead of the original site, which now trails them at #4. So much for the phrase’s competitiveness, huh ;)

  10. lazer epilasyon said,

    March 5, 2007 @ 3:31 pm

    thanks a lot for your really usefull articles.

  11. Ian C said,

    March 16, 2007 @ 2:34 pm

    Hi Phil,

    I just stumbled across this thread – a very enjoyable read. While I agree that the term is not competitive, I just wanted to mention that sometimes these phrases can be worth pursuing and act in accordance with a client’s true interests and not simply with their wishes.

    Yes, almost no search traffic exists for phrases such as these. But if your client is involved in an industry where a single lead can generate ‘x’ thousands of dollars and make up a significant chunk of their annual revenue, then optimizing for these phrases can still be an absolute money winner for the client. If your page has a 2% viewer to customer conversion rate, then even a meager 50 visitors a year looking for such a term results in a sale that more than justifies the expense and effort of optimizing for a non competitive phrase.

    I just wanted to mention this point lest some people think that optimizing for such a phrase is never in the client’s interest. Again… great article!

    All the best…

    Ian

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

index insurance buy auto insurance online apollo insurance hawaii insurance commission bike direct insurance health insurance jobs farmers insurance wichita contents insurance quotes allstate insurance online e insurance company caton insurance hotchkiss insurance farmers insurance seattle age concern holiday insurance asda car insurance accident medical insurance implant dental insurance halcyon insurance dairy insurance allstate insurance maine how to get home insurance gmac insurance service center gold card travel insurance how much car insurance do i need employment insurance benefits canada asda insurance dance instructor insurance kmart insurance health insurance glossary dog bite insurance allied insurance quote buy american insurance bullock insurance aj insurance car dealer insurance cis motor insurance compare home contents insurance calico insurance allstate insurance locations companion insurance directors insurance cheap lady car insurance globe life insurance rates health group insurance girls car insurance health insurance estimate farmers insurance bank kitten insurance aflac life insurance health insurance rates gmc auto insurance encompass insurance co bristol west auto insurance health insurance tucson health insurance in houston cheap uk car insurance insurance policies ghc insurance abbey national car insurance allstate insurance alabama amerisure insurance afc insurance gmc insurance kaiser insurance aa home insurance bixby insurance ct health insurance esquire insurance beacon one insurance california insurance ais car insurance health insurance guide cheap professional liability insurance appraisers errors and omissions insurance abco insurance aa car insurance quotes how much is homeowners insurance annual ski insurance alleghany insurance aegis security insurance bremer insurance health insurance privacy afl insurance federal dental insurance boat us insurance get gap insurance capital insurance agency az auto insurance hawaii renters insurance farmers fire insurance apex insurance services benchmark insurance company congress auto insurance employer group insurance indian harbor insurance kingsway motorcycle insurance hartford disability insurance budget direct car insurance airline ticket insurance haggerty insurance cheap health insurance washington builder liability insurance chartered insurance professional bond insurance health insurance cheap indiana homeowners insurance brit insurance insurance ombudsman birla life insurance catholic knights insurance society farm bureau insurance texas health net insurance plans aon insurance services aetna florida health insurance farmers insurance eugene hartland insurance duncan insurance agency direct response insurance health insurance colorado springs indianapolis insurance companies allied insurance nationwide health insurance plans ohio adriana's car insurance au pair insurance acordia insurance full dental insurance cheap car insurance london dui and insurance kanetix auto insurance amerus life insurance benesight insurance autoplan insurance bristol west insurance group health insurance providers australia all clear travel insurance health insurance employment health insurance china health insurance london central insurance child care liability insurance capital car insurance film production insurance cooperative insurance cheap medical insurance health insurance definitions kentucky health insurance course insurance health insurance companies in usa cobra insurance texas cheap house insurance house insurance michigan health net life insurance barr insurance computer quote insurance kaiser permanente insurance company hcsc insurance health insurance plan of greater ny furman insurance business liability insurance akc insurance health insurance rate comparison choice health insurance aegis insurance group good dental insurance farmers insurance simi valley baja insurance insurance institute how to buy term life insurance bad faith insurance car insurance broker health insurance finder boxborough insurance gio contents insurance direct insurance canada health insurance in wa state australia post insurance chubb auto insurance family medical insurance health insurance for pregnant women house rental insurance cat insurance uk bedford car insurance ian graham insurance alaska medical insurance dealer auto insurance cig insurance independent insurance agents of texas cis insurance kingsway insurance company direct line pet insurance athena insurance health insurance companies in new york kelly insurance ace usa insurance apex insurance company farmers insurance reviews calway insurance bluewater insurance fcci insurance group hartford school of insurance fortis life insurance car compare insurance cheap young driver car insurance dirigo health insurance car insurance for young drivers howard life insurance health insurance history barber insurance health insurance aetna farmers insurance agent login car commercial insurance calculate auto insurance bratrud middleton insurance health insurance houston tx farmers insurance commercial car insurance company aia insurance dance liability insurance corvel insurance health travel insurance fox insurance csa travel insurance health insurance in sc darwin insurance bell car insurance agreed value insurance backpacker holiday insurance family holiday insurance bristol west insurance co golden bear insurance farmers insurance las vegas bike shop insurance health insurance underwriting good auto insurance ace insurance limited goldfish travel insurance classic insurance quote health care insurance providers berkshire hathaway life insurance company of nebraska compare insurance uk compare term life insurance rates conway insurance ecar insurance howes insurance avmed health insurance bruners insurance boots insurance income protection insurance cost insurance freight final expense insurance leads health insurance florida all state renters insurance american southwest insurance how to be an insurance broker allstate insurance car commercial insurance health insurance broker illinois arbella mutual insurance company child life insurance policy custom bike insurance indiana low income health insurance gynecomastia insurance fema flood insurance cheap dental insurance plans indiana automobile insurance plan canada health insurance cba insurance blue cross travel insurance dean health insurance cooke insurance farmers insurance bill pay cheap holiday insurance uk frazier insurance cheap classic car insurance brush insurance condor insurance avian pet insurance eterm life insurance argonaut insurance co allison insurance oklahoma city how to become an insurance adjuster health insurance portland oregon gmac insurance quote aetna health insurance illinois diamond car insurance health insurance knoxville buy renters insurance columbia national insurance alliant insurance accident insurance employer life insurance alaska health insurance bluecross blueshield health insurance cheap life insurance cover health insurance premium increase health insurance hmo covermore travel insurance budget house insurance calculate homeowners insurance cna commercial insurance icici travel insurance esthetician insurance ace ina insurance allstate gap insurance chaucer car insurance farm family insurance compare car insurance prices health alliance insurance chubb home insurance hewitt insurance farmers insurance jobs annual travel insurance cheap idea insurance commonwealth life insurance annual travel insurance worldwide aa car insurance federal unemployment insurance crop insurance adjuster catamaran insurance annual travel insurance europe compare individual health insurance countrywide insurance different health insurance bergman insurance century homeowners insurance immediate car insurance afs health insurance americo financial life and annuity insurance company contents insurance sydney aaa keystone insurance eagle star insurance ct insurance jobs indemnity insurance definition health insurance south carolina care insurance esure car insurance fidelity guaranty life insurance co get liability insurance kaiser insurance georgia hcc insurance health insurance united health insurance ks federal deposit insurance corporation impact insurance health insurance search 65 health insurance health net medical insurance coresource insurance council insurance arch insurance services cooperators life insurance amex life insurance horace mann insurance insurance regulation cna life insurance assurant insurance atlantic auto insurance kanetix insurance quotes aetna health insurance oklahoma farmer union insurance cobra life insurance bob gabriel insurance citizens home insurance insurance sales how much is auto insurance health insurance premium payment program house insurance rates aig auto insurance health insurance plans in new jersey hartford insurance annuities aetna insurance ppo aa insurance services health insurance california health insurance cincinnati ohio aflac insurance company aig insurance reviews boyle insurance health insurance in ct cooperators auto insurance employers insurance company of wausau burbank insurance cheap car insurance toronto insurance coverage cheap health insurance kaiser health insurance california aa classic car insurance hartford underwriters insurance co clive insurance accident and health insurance federal flood insurance all state insurance rates dc health insurance all states insurance health insurance seniors health insurance plans in ny gladiator insurance services calpers long term care insurance health insurance new mexico allstate insurance jobs amica insurance address consumer report insurance age concern home insurance car dealership insurance kaiser health insurance plans benefits network insurance employment insurance quebec colorado division of insurance asurion insurance borrow against life insurance brierfield insurance company house insurance landlord indiana health insurance aig renters insurance cheap affordable health insurance kentucky car insurance quotes health insurance available bristow insurance cove insurance diamond insurance allstate car insurance blue chip health insurance eagle insurance company equity red star insurance knapp insurance health insurance rates california health insurance laws australia health insurance car insurance laws cheap florida car insurance adventure insurance gym insurance christian life insurance aetna long term care insurance kanawha insurance company index life insurance ccc insurance health insurance maternity coverage fire insurance maps best home insurance anthem group health insurance halifax motor insurance how to become an insurance underwriter estes insurance ash insurance health insurance reviews farmers insurance company aixam insurance how to buy auto insurance insurance dictionary bankers life insurance allstate insurance san diego harwood insurance change auto insurance ellsworth insurance canton insurance hap health insurance farmers insurance los angeles cash in transit insurance esthetics insurance health insurance san diego hbf insurance berkeley care insurance bc auto insurance quotes kaiser health insurance quotes consumer life insurance commercial property insurance building insurance quotes corinthian insurance cobra health insurance kentucky department of insurance ca car insurance quotes bcs life insurance company discount car insurance quotes dui auto insurance advanta insurance company bingham insurance aetna health insurance nj bannister insurance bouchard insurance careington dental insurance beech street insurance ka insurance allstate health insurance health insurance spokane wa hagerty car insurance health insurance plans for individuals aetna insurance forms cheap loan insurance black rock insurance archway insurance discount insurance plan aetna health insurance phone number covermore insurance aaa trip insurance discount house insurance health insurance sales leads baby health insurance auto insurance specialists 21rst century insurance allstate insurance auto